“Artists already have it hard competing with AI, ratchet, and low-vibrational music,” Gilbert said, emphasizing that character and meaningful artistry should outlast temporary trends.

Gilbert also expressed concern about the impact music can have on young women, saying she doesn’t believe songs centered around glorifying illegal activity or materialism provide healthy examples for future generations. While acknowledging that artists have the freedom to express themselves creatively, she questioned whether the industry has become too comfortable rewarding controversy over substance.

Her remarks quickly divided social media.

Supporters applauded Gilbert for speaking candidly about what they see as declining standards in popular music, arguing that influential artists should be more mindful of the messages they promote. Others agreed that today’s music industry often prioritizes shock value and viral moments over storytelling and positive representation.